Tag Archives: Personal finance coverage
Family first over business journalism
by Chris Roush
Katherine Rosman, a technology reporter for The Wall Street Journal, writes about why she is stopping writing the paper’s Checks & Balances about family personal finance after one year.
Rosman writes, “But it also has been a source of tension. As a writer, I know well that the only way to successfully put these columns together is by reflecting my feelings and Joe’s without any whitewashing. Yet as a wife, I know well that a marriage is inherently a trust that does not always benefit from having its private dynamics laid bare before seven million readers.
“To fulfill my responsibilities both to my editor and to my husband, I looked for everyday issues that represented my and Joe’s varying views, that I felt comfortable expounding upon with raw honesty and that might resonate with this column’s large and diverse readership. This tack produced some of the most popular pieces: Joe’s opposition to my Starbucks habit, why I didn’t change my last name when we married, and how Twitter and email have interfered with the rhythms of the home.
“However, coming up with a column idea every two weeks that serves its many masters became a greater and greater challenge. When I was feeling protective of our privacy, I would write more lifestyle-focused pieces: the importance to a marriage of having close friends, for instance, or how different tastes in food can affect family dinner.
“But my job was to write about money, and doing so began to feel overly invasive, especially to Joe. When he told me late last fall that he wanted his life to be just his, I told my editor that I was going to stop at the column’s one-year anniversary.”
Read more here.
Time to get a new personal finance guru?
by Chris Roush
Felix Salmon of Reuters writes that CNBC personal finance show host Suze Orman has lost her credibility in commenting about financial services products now that she has entered the field with her own.
Salmon writes, “But what I can’t do is simply say ‘you can trust Suze Orman.’ You can’t trust Orman on the subject of her competitors — which, now, includes every checking account in the country. You can’t trust Orman on investment advice. And I don’t trust Orman either on the value of credit scores and credit monitoring — a service she sells through MiFico for $50 per year.
“Orman’s heart is in the right place: none of her products are really bad. If you sign up for a one-month free trial of her newsletter, you don’t need to provide a credit card number: all you get is the newsletter for one month. If you then want to subscribe, you need to subscribe. That’s a sign of an honest merchant: Orman isn’t looking to rip anybody off.
“But if you want an impartial judge of whether to have a checking account or a prepaid debit card, Orman is certainly not the person to ask: she’s a full-fledged financial-services provider, now. Who will watch the watchdog? I think we need a new guru.”
Read more here.
CNBC personal finance guru Orman unveils debit card
by Chris Roush
Ron Lieber of The New York Times writes Monday about the new debit card being introduced by CNBC personal finance expert Suze Orman.
Lieber writes, “Ms. Orman seeks to broaden the debit card market by charging low fees and offering new services, including unlimited access to credit reports. She has put more than $1 million of her own money into the venture and is prepared to add more, since the product may not break even right away. But her move also raises so many questions that it is hard to even know where to start.
“How can the Approved card make money charging fees on par with those on Walmart’s cut-rate MoneyCard, while also paying a credit bureau for access to its services? Also, can it really be just fine with CNBC, where Ms. Orman has a weekly show, that her card will compete with products from companies she discusses frequently with viewers? And will her followers care that she is pushing purple pieces of plastic that will help her make money from their everyday spending?
“‘I couldn’t be more proud of this card if I tried,’ she said. ‘And it doesn’t really matter what I say. It matters what happens when somebody uses this baby.’
“Their choice to use it may be colored by the opportune moment in which Ms. Orman finds herself. Big banks have offended scores of consumers with new fees and account balance minimums. People seeking alternatives may well find what they are looking for in prepaid cards.”
Read more here.
NY paper cutting Sunday WSJ content for its own
by Chris Roush
Rex Smith, the editor of the Albany Times Union in New York, writes about the paper’s changed to its Sunday business section.
Smith writes, “You’ll notice the changes most if you have been a fan of the Sunday Wall Street Journal pages that we have published in our Business section for the past five years. Those pages, focusing on personal finance advice, are being replaced with a new Sunday Money page that we think will offer readers useful content in much less space and at considerably reduced expense.
“It’s not that we didn’t like the Journal pages. But in an era of diminished revenues, editors must choose where to spend a limited pool of dollars. Those pages cost us the equivalent of a full-time reporter’s pay and benefits. Local reporting is really what you expect the Times Union to deliver to you, and we promise to deliver it to you at a level of depth and quality that you won’t find elsewhere.
“With that as our goal, I can’t in good conscience sacrifice a local job and the unique reporting it can yield to preserve personal finance content similar to what you can find in so many other places.
“Because of production realities on our 41-year-old press, we have to shrink another section to match the newly configured Business section. Thus, our Perspective section will lose a half-page of content, while more than a page of advertising will move elsewhere in the paper.”
Read more here.
SmartMoney’s brand of personal finance
by Chris Roush
TALKING BIZ NEWS EXCLUSIVE
Jonathan Dahl is editor of SmartMoney magazine, the Dow Jones & Co. monthly that competes in the personal finance category against Kiplinger’s and Time Inc.’s Money.
Dahl oversaw the magazine and its Web site during the tumultuous financial crash that drew increased national attention to personal finance coverage. For 2008, the magazine’s “Tough Customer” column won a Deadline Club Award, one of several honors that year. Its investigative pieces on annuities and retirement funds helped lead to reforms within the industry and more oversight from Washington.
At the Journal, Dahl served as a reporter, senior writer and bureau chief. He was one of the founding editors of the “Weekend Journal” section. Earlier in his career, he covered such topics as the asbestos industry and homelessness. His story “Missing in America,” a first-person account of his search for a missing homeless brother, was nominated by the Journal for a Pulitzer Prize.
He came to SmartMoney in 2006. His book, “1,001 Things They Won’t Tell You” (Workman Publishing), is based on the magazine’s long-running “10 Things” column and reveals insider information from doctors, bankers and dozens of other professions. Dahl attended Columbia College, where he graduated summa cum laude and Phi Beta Kappa in 1980. He received his master’s degree from Columbia’s Graduate School of Journalism in 1981.
In an e-mail interview with Talking Biz News, Dahl discussed the magazine’s strategy and personal finance reporting in general. What follows is an edited transcript.
How do you define personal finance journalism?
I’d say the definition has been evolving. The field used to just mean service-oriented pieces about what to do with your money. But today, the best personal finance journalism educates readers about the industries that handle and affect their money, offering insights into how the companies operate. The field is much newsier now, with more investigative reporting and trend pieces, and covers both domestic and global markets.
In other words, the scope is pretty big.
How does SmartMoney differentiate its personal finance journalism from its competitors?
We go against the grain in three ways. When we redesigned the magazine last year, we returned to putting more long-form stories in the mix, so you’ll find not only good advice but also in-depth reporting and strong writing in SmartMoney — the hallmark of any good business publication. We’ve also gone out of our way to be visually attractive‹with clever covers and cool graphics that aren’t normally associated with personal finance coverage. And finally, we’re not afraid to be a little humorous — have you seen “DumbMoney” on our last page? (A recent example: the $100,000 razor).
It’s a different approach, but it’s working: The magazine and its website have either won or been nominated for 18 national awards in the past two years.
What are some of the key personal finance issues that the magazine will focus on in 2012?
It’s a long list: The future of the euro. The uncertainty over our own government’s plans for financial and health care reform. The inability to make money in any savings account. The troubled housing and job markets.
Ultimately, though, I think 2012 will be the year of reckoning for baby boomers. They can’t go on being so close to retirement age with not enough saved and shaky health plans. It’s an enormous and important class of folks facing one crisis after another.
How much does the magazine look to its sister business journalism operations The Wall Street Journal, Marketwatch, Barron’s and Dow Jones Newswires in deciding what to cover in the personal finance area?
We each offer a different product that reaches a slightly different audience, so we stay fairly separate in terms of developing story ideas.
But we all operate under the same high standards of journalism.
Tell us a little bit about Smartmony.com and how it also differentiates itself from competitors as well.
Unlike most competitors, Smartmoney.com has its own staff and produces the bulk of its own content. I’m particularly proud of how well it has responded to the changing needs of investors and consumers this year. Most personal finance sites rely on static tips that are recycled through the year, but SmartMoney.com is constantly revising its advice. Recently, we started something pretty unique: a “real-time advice” blog that gives the personal finance angle to breaking news throughout the day. Readers can immediately know now if a strong retail sales report will mean fewer shopping discounts, or how the declining euro might affect their 401(k) plan. It’s been such a success The Wall Street Journal runs many of those pieces on its own website.
Are there some personal finance issues that the magazine simply won’t touch or cover?
No.
Who is the average SmartMoney reader, and what are they getting out of the magazine?
They’re either fairly sophisticated about money or have decided they want to learn more about it. The majority are male, but we’re trying to change that with covers like “Why Women Get a Raw Deal on Retirement.” Of course, we hope that SmartMoney readers are becoming –sorry about this — “smart” about their finances. But we also want them to enjoy or be intrigued by the experience of reading the magazine. Personal finance shouldn’t feel like homework.
What topics do you consider to be the strengths of SmartMoney’s coverage?
We’ve been ahead of the game in warning readers about a litany of financial moves and products, like brokers sticking people’s excess cash into worthless “sweep accounts” or not acting as your “fiduciary” (which means they don’t have to act in your best interest). A lot of publications have followed these stories later. Our stock picks aren’t too bad either: We’ve beaten the market seven years in a row now.
But I think our biggest strength has been keeping an eye on the larger picture. With all that was happening with the markets, we knew that by midsummer the basic tenets of how most people invest had to change‹hence, our “Investing Reinvented” cover. (We used an Einstein image for that.) We also recognized early that boomers were facing a host of new headaches, and highlighted them with covers like “The Rising Cost of a Midlife Crisis.” And we had great timing last spring with “The Power of Gold” (blessed with a great closeup image of a gold bar). It’s efforts like these that I think prove personal finance can be newsy.
Any areas where it could improve its coverage?
We feel like we cover all the important bases, but we’re always looking to include more stories that could better predict where markets are heading.
As we dive into longer form stories, the art of strong storytelling becomes more important too. We’re focusing some of our efforts there and hiring accordingly.
Should SmartMoney readers do what its stories say, or should they also get advice from finance professionals before making such decisions?
Great question, and the answer is no, don’t listen to just us. We want you to use SmartMoney as a guide for investing, but still work in most cases with a professional who knows your needs. That’s part of the objection we have to personal finance stories that try to tell people what to do: Each of us has our own individual financial issues and needs to customize our finances accordingly.
But we also think you should know how those professionals work, what their conflicts of interest are, and how they get paid. I think I know a good magazine that might be able to help with that.
Journalists win awards for personal finance coverage
by Chris Roush
Three journalists have won awards for in-depth stories that have improved the financial literacy of minorities across the United States.
The award winners were among 42 reporters who participated in a 12-week program administered by International Center for Journalists and funded by The McGraw-Hill Companies on personal finance reporting.
Heather Scofield, staff writer at The Durango Herald in Colorado, won first place for her front-page articles on immigrants slipping through cracks in the country’s health system. Focusing on one family’s struggle to get health insurance, she highlighted how some Hispanic groups — even those in the country legally — are regularly turned down for coverage.
Scofield explains how this burdens the local economy, especially strapped social welfare agencies. She also wrote a sidebar on what is working in the health system and how policies are changing to accommodate immigrant communities.
Second-place winner Yezmin Thomas of Telemundo created a multimedia report on how the recession is hurting migrant workers in Fort Worth, Texas. Their American dream, she writes, has turned into the reality of barely making ends meet as day laborers. Thomas then “zooms out” and examines the important role that the Hispanic labor force plays in the U.S. economy.
Third-place honoree Jeff Kelly Lowenstein worked with Loyola University to research and analyze the demographic trends of minority communities on the outskirts of Chicago. In his multimedia-rich story on a revitalization plan in the mostly Hispanic neighborhood of Pilsen, published on Hoy Chicago’s website, he reveals how these projects are displacing Hispanics instead of employing them.
The winners were honored in New York on Wednesday. Other participants focused on topics such as money management among young Latino professionals in Washington, D.C., and how the medically uninsured can get affordable treatment.
Read more here. DISCLOSURE: I was one of the instructors of the ICFJ personal finance course, and Scofield was one of my students.
Ex-CNBC anchor Lapin launches personal finance site
by Chris Roush
Nicole Lapin, a CNBC anchor who left the business network earlier this year, launched Recessionista.com, a personal finance website aimed at women between the ages of 18 and 34.
The site will offer financial guidance and investing advice to young women who aspire to be frugal during the economic recession.
In addition to providing women with practical career advice such as “5 Things NEVER to Wear to Work” or “How to Play to Your Work Weaknesses,” the site will aim to decode often intimidating financial topics in an easy-to-navigate format.
“It is not a coincidence that Recessionista is the first initiative launched by Nothing But Gold Productions,” said Lapin, CEO of Nothing But Gold, in a statement. “The financial journalism world is devoid of content specifically geared towards women my age. We are in dire need of advice and information to intelligently guide our financial decisions in a fun, sassy, non-judgey way.”
The site will also provide money-saving tips and advice for building a career and thriving in the workplace. The site will also feature celebrity interviews and profiles of successful female entrepreneurs.
Read more here.
Motley Fool looking for bloggers to write about stocks and markets
by Chris Roush
The Motley Fool is a month or two away from rolling out a blog network covering the worlds of investing and business. Its goal is to attract the best and brightest contributors and to make the blogging process as easy as possible.
Bloggers will be able to post as often as they’d like, cross-post from their own blog, and get paid in the process — or choose to donate to charity.
Further, posts contributed to the network could be distributed to the major finance sites — Yahoo! Finance, AOL DailyFinance, MSN Money, CNNMoney, and more — and can be featured on Fool.com and in its emails that are sent to millions of registered users.
The Alexandria, Va.-based company is still hammering out the details of the network — it should be rolling out an early version in a month or so.
If you are interested in taking part, send an e-mail to Roger Friedman, president of the Motley Fool Blog Network, at rfriedman@fool.com. Tell him that you saw this post on Talking Biz News.
Appreciating good personal finance coverage
by Chris Roush
Bob Mong, the editor of the Dallas Morning News, writes about the paper’s personal finance columnist, Pamela Yip.
Mong writes, “Readers tell us they expect superb coverage of personal finance. That’s why Pam Yip is assigned to the beat full time.
“Pam engages with many segments of our readership: well-off investors unnerved by the market volatility; seniors concerned about their savings; relatives seeking advice for unemployed family members; and mid-career folks negotiating a tough economy.
“Her reach is impressive.
“Recent columns touched on issues as diverse as understanding credit reports, finding competent financial advice, selecting health coverage and going through financial planning for the end of the year.
“Last weekend, she invited financial planners to our offices to take reader calls.
“Her column Monday will focus on how to strike a balance between helping your adult children and not jeopardizing your own financial future.Her column tomorrow will focus on how to deal with adult children still living at home.
“Pam also launched a financial planning blog on dallasnews.com.
“She is so trustworthy that some readers allow her to match them up with experts to review family finances. In these exercises, financial analysts look over a family’s finances and recommend ways to make the most of their wealth. The service is free.”
WSJ’s Arends goes against the herd
by Chris Roush
Pamela Yellen of The Huffington Post writes that Wall Street Journal personal finance reporter Brett Arends is the best in the field.
Yellen writes, “Arends, 43, a personal finance columnist with The Wall Street Journal, often finds himself going against the herd — even at his own newspaper.
“A financial journalist in Europe and the U.S. since the 1990s, Arends writes the daily R.O.I. column for WSJ.com, examining the intersection of personal finance and current affairs. His articles also regularly appear in the print edition of the Journal and at MarketWatch.com.
“Arends notes in the introduction to his 2009 book, Storm Proof Your Money…
“‘I never really trust somebody until I’ve heard them say two things: ‘I don’t know’ and ‘I was wrong.’
“Among the recent myth-busting notches on his editorial belt: Ten Stock Market Myths That Just Won’t Die (July 25, 2010); The Ten Biggest Myths About Gold (September 17, 2010); Seven Myths and Realities About Taxes (September 28, 2010); and 10 Market Myths Debunked (October 5, 2011).”
Read more here.




